So, Arena is honestly pretty fun, and I've played a feature I never touched before via the seasonal arenas.
Want to know why I never played Arena before? It takes way too long. Because of the forced cooldowns, you're committed to sitting there babysitting it for 20+ minutes if you want to get a game done, and spending a tiny fraction of that actually playing. It's an annoying mixture of not having enough time to decide what goes on your team and scroll down to it, especially on mobile, and spending too much time sitting there waiting.
I get the delays in PvP, but, well, I haven't played an Arena game that actually had another user in it since beta testing. I suspect the matter that it takes roughly forever scares most folks off. There's no reason to sit there and wait for the bots to make their decisions. The seasonal Arena format is better in every way. I think having a PvP option onsite is neat, but especially since there are apparel and companions that are only available via Arena, the absurd wait times shouldn't be the only option to get the vouchers and achievements. So here are some solutions that would make regular Arena a more enjoyable experience and/or make the voucher and playing games achievements obtainable with seasonal arena, ordered by how useful I think they'd be.
- Add an option for PvE arena. It's like seasonal arena except with normal companion setups. Skips the cooldowns, all opponents are bots, you have as much time to decide your team between rounds as you want. You can still access regular arena via a separate PvP option.
- Go into PvE mode automatically if the player has waited through the full cooldown for other players to join and everyone is bots. You don't need to wait for the bots to make decisions, after all.
- When in "PvP" mode, provide an option to skip cooldowns once all players have said they're ready. Bots, of course, can be ready at any time.
- Make seasonal Arena count for the "play games of Arena" achievement. I don't know why it doesn't.
- Make seasonal Arena drop Arena Vouchers, probably at a lower rate than seasonal vouchers so there's still reason to play regular Arena, but so the achievement and Arena items are obtainable given enough time.